Totals
- Total revenue
- $415,813,177
- Total expenses
- $405,558,235
- Contributions and grants received
- $415,013,229
- Grants paid
- $0
- Program service revenue
- $17,087
- Investment income
- $1,070,718
- Other revenue
- -$287,857
- Total assets, end of year
- $425,697,419
- Total liabilities, end of year
- $408,540,028
- Net assets or fund balances, end of year
- $17,157,391
- Program services expenses (Part IX)
- $371,907,320
- Management and general expenses
- $31,446,586
- Fundraising expenses
- $2,204,329
- Program service expenses (Part III)
- $371,907,320
Program services were 91.7% of total expenses calculated — Part IX's program-services column over total expenses, both as filed.
Line items
Every line the filer filed in Parts VIII, IX and X, as filed and in filed order. Blank columns are left out, and the lines are not forced to add up to the totals above.
Revenue
Part VIII, the statement of revenue.
-
1c · Fundraising events
$2,626,575
-
1e · Government grants (contributions)
$379,966,233
-
1f · All other contributions, gifts and grants
$32,420,421
-
1g · Noncash contributions included above
$214,975
-
2a · Program service revenue: COURT AWARDS
total $17,087 · related or exempt $17,087
-
3 · Investment income
total $1,089,214 · excluded $1,089,214
-
7a · Gross sales of assets other than inventory
securities $10,128,519
-
7b · Less cost or other basis and sales expenses
securities $10,147,015
-
7c · Gain or loss
securities -$18,496
-
7d · Net gain or loss
total -$18,496 · excluded -$18,496
-
8a · Fundraising events: gross income
$121,510
-
8a · Fundraising events: contributions included on line 1c
$2,626,575
-
8b · Fundraising events: direct expenses
$539,334
-
8c · Net income from fundraising events
total -$417,824 · excluded -$417,824
-
11a · Other revenue: BENEFIT COST REIMBURSEMENTS
total $129,079 · excluded $129,079
-
11b · Other revenue: MISC. INCOME
total $888 · excluded $888
-
11e · Other revenue, total
$129,967
Functional expenses
Part IX, the statement of functional expenses.
-
5 · Compensation of officers, directors and key employees
total $2,549,934 · program services $2,381,128 · management and general $156,566 · fundraising $12,240
-
7 · Other salaries and wages
total $227,661,410 · program services $212,595,418 · management and general $13,974,132 · fundraising $1,091,860
-
8 · Pension plan contributions
total $30,048,258 · program services $28,417,905 · management and general $1,480,072 · fundraising $150,281
-
9 · Other employee benefits
total $61,431,190 · program services $58,090,049 · management and general $3,029,529 · fundraising $311,612
-
10 · Payroll taxes
total $19,080,563 · program services $18,044,385 · management and general $940,766 · fundraising $95,412
-
11c · Fees: accounting
total $352,819 · management and general $352,819
-
11d · Fees: lobbying
total $120,290 · management and general $120,290
-
11e · Fees: professional fundraising services
total $111,376 · fundraising $111,376
-
11f · Fees: investment management
total $64,743 · management and general $64,743
-
11g · Fees: other
total $10,239,828 · program services $5,338,221 · management and general $4,783,107 · fundraising $118,500
-
12 · Advertising and promotion
total $200,870 · management and general $199,298 · fundraising $1,572
-
13 · Office expenses
total $2,891,799 · program services $1,792,355 · management and general $1,091,257 · fundraising $8,187
-
16 · Occupancy
total $30,601,040 · program services $30,202,215 · management and general $398,005 · fundraising $820
-
17 · Travel
total $1,001,629 · program services $956,514 · management and general $44,548 · fundraising $567
-
19 · Conferences, conventions and meetings
total $296,208 · program services $201,852 · management and general $91,216 · fundraising $3,140
-
20 · Interest
total $26,803 · management and general $26,803
-
22 · Depreciation, depletion and amortization
total $1,281,641 · program services $458,428 · management and general $823,213
-
23 · Insurance
total $893,989 · program services $761,170 · management and general $132,796 · fundraising $23
-
24a · Other expenses: EQUIPMENT RENTAL/MAINT.
total $5,229,268 · program services $3,372,585 · management and general $1,745,521 · fundraising $111,162
-
24b · Other expenses: INVESTIGATIONS
total $2,471,540 · program services $2,471,540
-
24c · Other expenses: COMMUNICATIONS
total $2,231,313 · program services $2,139,520 · management and general $86,498 · fundraising $5,295
-
24d · Other expenses: LAW BOOKS & MATERIALS
total $1,393,347 · program services $1,357,365 · management and general $31,426 · fundraising $4,556
-
24e · All other expenses
total $5,378,377 · program services $3,326,670 · management and general $1,873,981 · fundraising $177,726
Balance sheet
Part X, book values.
-
1 · Cash, non-interest-bearing
beginning of year $16,847,078 · end of year $6,993,993
-
2 · Savings and temporary cash investments
beginning of year $25,195,717 · end of year $11,515,881
-
3 · Pledges and grants receivable
beginning of year $106,927,375 · end of year $137,022,104
-
9 · Prepaid expenses and deferred charges
beginning of year $2,436,806 · end of year $1,443,621
-
10a · Land, buildings and equipment: cost or other basis
$28,196,330
-
10b · Land, buildings and equipment: accumulated depreciation
$15,806,927
-
10c · Land, buildings and equipment, net
beginning of year $11,524,671 · end of year $12,389,403
-
11 · Investments: publicly traded securities
beginning of year $5,457,480 · end of year $6,171,290
-
12 · Investments: other securities
beginning of year $3,896,865 · end of year $12,392,800
-
15 · Other assets
beginning of year $313,696,316 · end of year $237,768,327
-
17 · Accounts payable and accrued expenses
beginning of year $57,187,593 · end of year $61,729,850
-
25 · Other liabilities
beginning of year $419,582,414 · end of year $346,810,178
-
27 · Net assets without donor restrictions
beginning of year $2,111,689 · end of year $6,912,396
-
28 · Net assets with donor restrictions
beginning of year $7,100,612 · end of year $10,244,995
Mission and programs · 2023
Mission
THE LEGAL AID SOCIETY IS A PRIVATE, NOT-FOR-PROFIT LEGAL SERVICES ORGANIZATION, THE OLDEST AND LARGEST IN THE NATION, DEDICATED SINCE 1876 TO PROVIDING QUALITY LEGAL REPRESENTATION TO LOW-INCOME NEW YORKERS. (MISSION CONTINUED ON SCHEDULE O)IT IS DEDICATED TO ONE SIMPLE BUT POWERFUL BELIEF: THAT NO NEW YORKER SHOULD BE DENIED ACCESS TO JUSTICE BECAUSE OF POVERTY. DURING THE YEAR, THE SOCIETY HANDLED MORE THAN 208,607 INDIVIDUAL CASES AND MATTERS AND PROVIDED A COMPREHENSIVE RANGE OF LEGAL SERVICES IN THREE AREAS: THE CIVIL, CRIMINAL AND JUVENILE RIGHTS PRACTICES. UNLIKE THE SOCIETY'S CRIMINAL AND JUVENILE RIGHTS PRACTICES, WHICH ARE LEGALLY MANDATED AND SUPPORTED BY THE GOVERNMENT, THE CIVIL PRACTICE RELIES HEAVILY ON PRIVATE CONTRIBUTIONS.
Activities or mission (Part I)
TO PROVIDE QUALITY LEGAL REPRESENTATION TO LOW-INCOME NEW YORKERS.
-
CRIMINAL PRACTICE - REPRESENTED NYC INDIGENT CLIENTS INVOLVING CRIMINAL DEFENSE TRIAL, APPELLATE, POST-CONVICTION AND PAROLE REVOCATION DEFENSE MATTERS. IT IS ESTIMATED THAT THE CRIMINAL PRACTICE WORKED ON APPROXIMATELY 126,303 CLIENT MATTERS THIS YEAR.
Expenses $220,930,249
-
CIVIL PRACTICE - PROVIDED CIVIL LEGAL ASSISTANCE TO LOW-INCOME NEW YORKERS AND WORKED ON APPROXIMATELY 59,000 CLIENT MATTERS THIS YEAR.
Expenses $98,706,740 · Revenue $17,087
-
JUVENILE RIGHTS PRACTICE - REPRESENTED CHILDREN AND YOUNG ADULTS WHO ARE THE SUBJECT OF ABUSE AND NEGLECT, DELINQUENCY AND OTHER MATTERS IN THE NYC FAMILY COURT. IT IS ESTIMATED THAT THE JUVENILE RIGHTS PRACTICE WORKED ON APPROXIMATELY 23,304 ONGOING CLIENT MATTERS THIS YEAR.
Expenses $52,270,331
As filed on the 2023 return. The filer continues this part on Schedule O, which is not shown here.
Listed in Part VII
-
RICHARD F ALBERT
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
DEBORAH N ARCHER
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
CHRISTOPHER D BELELIEU
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
BARRY A BOHRER
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JOHN K CARROLL
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
NANCY CHUNG
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
EVA W COLE
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ROGER A COOPER
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
SARAH COYNE
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JENNA M DABBS
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MATTHEW DILLER
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MARY EATON
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
SCOTT A EDELMAN
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MAURICIO ESPANA
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
NATASHA I FAPOHUNDA
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
EDWARD FLANDERS
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JEFFREY A FUISZ
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MATTHEW FURMAN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
RAJ GANDESHA
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JEFFREY GLEN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MIA N GONZALEZ
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MEAGHAN GRAGG
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
CAROL GREENE-VINCENT
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
HELEN GUGEL
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ADAM HAKKI
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
DAVID G HILLE
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
RICHARD F HANS
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
NOLA HELLER
DIRECTOR (FROM 9/25/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
TALEAH JENNINGS
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MICHAEL C KEATS
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ELAI KATZ
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ATIF KHAWAJA
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MARVIN KRISLOV
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
GILLIAN LESTER
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
CYNTHIA FERNANDEZ LUMERMANN
DIRECTOR (FROM 4/17/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
AARON R MARCU
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
J KEVIN MCCARTHY
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JOAN MCPHEE
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
PERRY A NAPOLITANO
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
LYNN K NEUNER
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
AMANDA T PEREZ
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
CHARLES C PLATT
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
PATRICK T QUINN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
SHARYL A REISMAN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
KATHERINE ROCCO
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ALYSSA ROWER
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
DANIEL RUBENS
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ANTONY L RYAN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
WILLIAM SAVITT
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
PAUL H SCHOEMAN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
BART R SCHWARTZ
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
WILLIAM SCHWARTZ
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
IAN SHAPIRO
DIRECTOR (FROM 1/19/24)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
L KEVIN SHERIDAN JR
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
RACHEL SHERMAN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
TIFFANY J SMITH
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
AUDRA J SOLOWAY
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JOSEPH L SORKIN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
RICHARD STRASSBERG
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
KIM A WALKER
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
CHARLES WEINSTEIN
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
PETER M WILLIAMS
DIRECTOR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JAMIE L WINE
DIRECTOR (THRU 12/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
ALAN LEVINE
PRESIDENT
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 10
-
DAVID GREENWALD
TREASURER
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 10
-
ZACHARY W CARTER
CHAIRMAN
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 10
-
LARA S BUCHWALD
VICE CHAIR (FROM 1/18/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
JUNE S DIPCHAND
VICE CHAIR (FROM 1/18/23)
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
MARK P GOODMAN
VICE CHAIR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
TRACY RICHELLE HIGH
VICE CHAIR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
BRADLEY I RUSKIN
VICE CHAIR
- Total calculated
- $0
- Hours/week
- 1
-
SCOTT A ROSENBERG
GENERAL COUNSEL & SECRETARY
- Total calculated
- $350,992
- From this org
- $253,617
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $97,375
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $248,164
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $5,453
- Deferred
- $32,182
- Nontaxable benefits
- $65,193
- Filer's total
- $350,992
-
TWYLA J CARTER
ATTORNEY-IN-CHIEF/CEO
- Total calculated
- $326,687
- From this org
- $281,940
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $44,747
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $281,802
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $138
- Deferred
- $19,135
- Nontaxable benefits
- $25,612
- Filer's total
- $326,687
-
LAUREN SICILIANO
CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
- Total calculated
- $293,473
- From this org
- $251,276
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $42,197
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $251,216
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $60
- Deferred
- $17,049
- Nontaxable benefits
- $25,148
- Filer's total
- $293,473
-
PREMALI SHAH
CFO (THRU 10/13/23)
- Total calculated
- $289,032
- From this org
- $229,460
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $59,572
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $214,358
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $15,102
- Deferred
- $0
- Nontaxable benefits
- $59,572
- Filer's total
- $289,032
-
DAWNE A MITCHELL
CHIEF ATTORNEY - JRP
- Total calculated
- $336,160
- From this org
- $251,980
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $84,180
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $247,011
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $4,969
- Deferred
- $20,177
- Nontaxable benefits
- $64,003
- Filer's total
- $336,160
-
JUSTINE LUONGO
CHIEF ATTORNEY - CDP
- Total calculated
- $335,751
- From this org
- $250,107
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $85,644
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $245,138
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $4,969
- Deferred
- $17,355
- Nontaxable benefits
- $68,289
- Filer's total
- $335,751
-
ADRIENE L HOLDER
CHIEF ATTORNEY - CIVIL
- Total calculated
- $299,973
- From this org
- $257,265
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $42,708
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $252,296
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $4,969
- Deferred
- $18,640
- Nontaxable benefits
- $24,068
- Filer's total
- $299,973
-
CONNIE A PARK CHIEF HUMAN
RESOURCES OFFICER (FROM 04/10/2023)
- Total calculated
- $192,100
- From this org
- $161,135
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $30,965
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $157,729
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $3,406
- Deferred
- $14,687
- Nontaxable benefits
- $16,278
- Filer's total
- $192,100
-
SURYA SAYED-GANGULY
CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICER
- Total calculated
- $312,035
- From this org
- $230,908
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $81,127
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $212,251
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $18,657
- Deferred
- $15,688
- Nontaxable benefits
- $65,439
- Filer's total
- $312,035
-
LOUIS S SARTORI
CHIEF COUNSEL, PRO BONO PRACTICE
- Total calculated
- $286,161
- From this org
- $205,904
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $80,257
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $188,943
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $16,961
- Deferred
- $18,327
- Nontaxable benefits
- $61,930
- Filer's total
- $286,161
-
JASON WU
ATTORNEY-IN-CHARGE
- Total calculated
- $285,826
- From this org
- $212,252
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $73,574
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $157,634
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $54,618
- Deferred
- $11,591
- Nontaxable benefits
- $61,983
- Filer's total
- $285,826
-
DAVID E LOFTIS
ATTORNEY-IN-CHARGE
- Total calculated
- $279,788
- From this org
- $205,480
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $74,308
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $188,798
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $16,682
- Deferred
- $13,878
- Nontaxable benefits
- $60,430
- Filer's total
- $279,788
-
IRWIN SHAW
ATTORNEY-IN-CHARGE-BOROUGH
- Total calculated
- $258,130
- From this org
- $213,704
- From related orgs
- $0
- Other
- $44,426
- Hours/week
- 35
Schedule J breakdown matched by us
- Base
- $198,025
- Bonus
- $0
- Other
- $15,679
- Deferred
- -$19,047
- Nontaxable benefits
- $63,473
- Filer's total
- $258,130
Compensation is as filed in Part VII: reportable pay from this organization and from related organizations, other compensation, and hours per week. The total, marked calculated, is our sum of the three dollar columns, with a blank column counted as $0; the form itself has no total. On a Form 990-EZ the columns are Part IV's instead, and on a Form 990-PF Part VIII's — compensation, contributions to benefit plans, and expense account — and the total sums those. A Schedule J breakdown is as filed: base pay, bonus, other, deferred compensation and nontaxable benefits from this organization, with any from related organizations beside each, and the filer's own total. It is shown with the Part VII listing of the same name on the same return. The form gives no key between the two, so that pairing is ours, and is marked matched by us.
Schedule J
Answered yes
- 3 · Compensation committee
- 3 · Form 990 of other organizations
- 3 · Compensation survey or study
- 3 · Approval by the board or compensation committee
- 4a · Severance or change-of-control payment
Answered no
- 4b · Supplemental nonqualified retirement plan
- 4c · Equity-based compensation arrangement
- 5a · Pay contingent on this organization's revenues
- 5b · Pay contingent on a related organization's revenues
- 6a · Pay contingent on this organization's net earnings
- 6b · Pay contingent on a related organization's net earnings
- 7 · Other non-fixed payments
- 8 · Paid under the initial-contract exception
The filer's explanations (Part III)
- PART I, LINE 4A
- PREMALI SHAH, CFO, RESIGNED FROM THE LEGAL AID SOCIETY ON 10/13/2023 AND RECEIVED A LUMP-SUM SALARY PAYMENT OF $148,431, WHICH IS REFLECTED ON PREMALI'S 2024 W-2.
- PART II, COLUMN B(III):
- THE AMOUNT REPORTED IN OTHER REPORTABLE COMPENSATION FOR JASON WU INCLUDES DOMESTIC PARTNER IMPUTED INCOME.
- PART II, COLUMN C:
- THE AMOUNTS REPORTED INCLUDE THE ESTIMATED INCREASE/DECREASE IN THE ACTUARIAL VALUE OF THE DEFINED BENEFIT PLAN ACCRUALS.
Part I's answers as filed. A line not listed was left unanswered; on lines 1a and 3 that means the box was not checked.
Grants on this return
No itemized grants to organizations on this return.
Provenance
- Return type
- form_990
- Tax year
- 2023
- Filed
- 12 May 2025
- IRS schema version
- 2023v6.0
- Source object
- 202541329349305114
Check it against the return as filed: the GivingTuesday Data Lake hosts a public copy of the original XML.
The source document this was parsed from is served over the API, which is where bulk and document access live.