Skip to content
Nonprofiteer
← COLLEGE INSURANCE COMPANY

Form 990 for tax year 2024

Filed by COLLEGE INSURANCE COMPANY.

Totals

Total revenue
$36,291,433
Total expenses
$34,894,035
Contributions and grants received
$0
Grants paid
$0
Program service revenue
$32,748,063
Investment income
$3,543,370
Other revenue
$0
Total assets, end of year
$88,107,064
Total liabilities, end of year
$50,599,056
Net assets or fund balances, end of year
$37,508,008
Program services expenses (Part IX)
$32,293,768
Management and general expenses
$2,600,267
Fundraising expenses
$0
Program service expenses (Part III)
$32,293,768

Program services were 92.5% of total expenses calculated — Part IX's program-services column over total expenses, both as filed.

Line items

Every line the filer filed in Parts VIII, IX and X, as filed and in filed order. Blank columns are left out, and the lines are not forced to add up to the totals above.

Revenue

Part VIII, the statement of revenue.

  • 2a · Program service revenue: PREMIUMS EARNED

    total $32,347,214 · related or exempt $29,647,676 · unrelated business $2,699,538

  • 2b · Program service revenue: COMMISSIONS EARNED

    total $400,849 · related or exempt $400,849

  • 3 · Investment income

    total $2,847,001 · excluded $2,847,001

  • 7a · Gross sales of assets other than inventory

    securities $13,432,701

  • 7b · Less cost or other basis and sales expenses

    securities $12,736,332

  • 7c · Gain or loss

    securities $696,369

  • 7d · Net gain or loss

    total $696,369 · excluded $696,369

Functional expenses

Part IX, the statement of functional expenses.

  • 4 · Benefits paid to or for members

    total $29,815,491 · program services $29,815,491

  • 11a · Fees: management

    total $2,154,000 · management and general $2,154,000

  • 11b · Fees: legal

    total $83 · management and general $83

  • 11c · Fees: accounting

    total $55,883 · management and general $55,883

  • 11f · Fees: investment management

    total $147,991 · management and general $147,991

  • 11g · Fees: other

    total $208,937 · management and general $208,937

  • 17 · Travel

    total $7,776 · management and general $7,776

  • 23 · Insurance

    total $25,597 · management and general $25,597

  • 24a · Other expenses: COMMISSION EXPENSE

    total $2,226,007 · program services $2,226,007

  • 24b · Other expenses: UNDERWRITING EXPENSE

    total $122,984 · program services $122,984

  • 24c · Other expenses: PREMIUM TAX EXPENSE

    total $117,734 · program services $117,734

  • 24e · All other expenses

    total $11,552 · program services $11,552

Balance sheet

Part X, book values.

  • 2 · Savings and temporary cash investments

    beginning of year $13,943,802 · end of year $8,281,559

  • 4 · Accounts receivable

    beginning of year $739,462 · end of year $488,416

  • 11 · Investments: publicly traded securities

    beginning of year $66,305,624 · end of year $77,508,481

  • 15 · Other assets

    beginning of year $1,018,787 · end of year $1,828,608

  • 17 · Accounts payable and accrued expenses

    beginning of year $2,794,171 · end of year $3,627,053

  • 19 · Deferred revenue

    beginning of year $267,103 · end of year $266,397

  • 25 · Other liabilities

    beginning of year $43,405,892 · end of year $46,705,606

  • 29 · Capital stock, trust principal or current funds

    beginning of year $0 · end of year $0

  • 30 · Paid-in or capital surplus, or land, building or equipment fund

    beginning of year $2,750,154 · end of year $2,750,154

  • 31 · Retained earnings, endowment or other funds

    beginning of year $32,790,355 · end of year $34,757,854

Mission and programs · 2024

Mission

COLLEGE PROVIDES VARIOUS INSURANCE COVERAGES TO EDUCATIONAL & INSTITUTIONAL INSURANCE ADMINISTRATORS, INC. (EIIA), AND ITS PARTICIPATING HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS, THAT ARE FAITH INSPIRED.

Activities or mission (Part I)

PROVIDES PROPERTY AND CASUALTY, STUDENT, AND EMPLOYEE BENEFIT COVERAGES TO FAITH INSPIRED HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS

  • PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE, STUDENT INSURANCE AND EMPLOYEE BENEFITS INSURANCE.

    Expenses $32,293,768 · Revenue $30,048,525

As filed on the 2024 return.

Listed in Part VII

  • Mr David Dietz

    PRESIDENT/CHAIR

    Total calculated
    $788,506
    From this org
    $0
    From related orgs
    $641,339
    Other
    $147,167
    Hours/week
    2 + 35.5 related

    Schedule J breakdown matched by us

    Base
    $0 + $537,549 related
    Bonus
    $0 + $98,900 related
    Other
    $0 + $4,890 related
    Deferred
    $0 + $96,070 related
    Nontaxable benefits
    $0 + $51,097 related
    Filer's total
    $0 + $788,506 related
  • Mr Kirk Anderson

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Jeff Arnold

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Dr Mark Benedetto

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Belinda Burke

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Dr John Comerford

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr John Flynn

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Rochelle Ford

    DIRECTOR (TO JUL '24)

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Dr Wesley Fugate

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Meredith Green

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Deborah Hall

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Dr Sandra Harper

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Stephanie Herseth Sandlin

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Gerald Ladner

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Michael Maxey

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Dave Provost

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Wilda Seymour

    DIRECTOR (TO MAR '24)

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Jeffrey Straits

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Dr Troy Vanaken

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Karen Ward

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Rev Lamont Wells

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Dr Harold Wilde

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Chris Wood

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Mr Michael Zuckerman

    DIRECTOR

    Total calculated
    $0
    Hours/week
    0.5 + 1 related
  • Ms Mary Ellen Moriarty

    VP/ASSISTANT SECRETARY

    Total calculated
    $477,678
    From this org
    $0
    From related orgs
    $400,218
    Other
    $77,460
    Hours/week
    2 + 35.5 related

    Schedule J breakdown matched by us

    Base
    $0 + $322,000 related
    Bonus
    $0 + $65,466 related
    Other
    $0 + $12,752 related
    Deferred
    $0 + $58,250 related
    Nontaxable benefits
    $0 + $19,210 related
    Filer's total
    $0 + $477,678 related
  • Mr Stephen L Garwood

    TREASURER/SECRETARY

    Total calculated
    $486,846
    From this org
    $0
    From related orgs
    $391,324
    Other
    $95,522
    Hours/week
    2 + 35.5 related

    Schedule J breakdown matched by us

    Base
    $0 + $319,591 related
    Bonus
    $0 + $58,981 related
    Other
    $0 + $12,752 related
    Deferred
    $0 + $57,403 related
    Nontaxable benefits
    $0 + $38,119 related
    Filer's total
    $0 + $486,846 related
  • Mr Gregory Logan

    ASSISTANT SECRETARY

    Total calculated
    $351,095
    From this org
    $0
    From related orgs
    $272,847
    Other
    $78,248
    Hours/week
    2 + 35.5 related

    Schedule J breakdown matched by us

    Base
    $0 + $226,182 related
    Bonus
    $0 + $41,915 related
    Other
    $0 + $4,750 related
    Deferred
    $0 + $40,832 related
    Nontaxable benefits
    $0 + $37,416 related
    Filer's total
    $0 + $351,095 related
  • Mr Donald J Cencula Jr

    ASSISTANT TREASURER

    Total calculated
    $282,611
    From this org
    $0
    From related orgs
    $203,522
    Other
    $79,089
    Hours/week
    2 + 35.5 related

    Schedule J breakdown matched by us

    Base
    $0 + $185,157 related
    Bonus
    $0 + $12,782 related
    Other
    $0 + $5,583 related
    Deferred
    $0 + $30,511 related
    Nontaxable benefits
    $0 + $48,578 related
    Filer's total
    $0 + $282,611 related

Compensation is as filed in Part VII: reportable pay from this organization and from related organizations, other compensation, and hours per week. The total, marked calculated, is our sum of the three dollar columns, with a blank column counted as $0; the form itself has no total. On a Form 990-EZ the columns are Part IV's instead, and on a Form 990-PF Part VIII's — compensation, contributions to benefit plans, and expense account — and the total sums those. A Schedule J breakdown is as filed: base pay, bonus, other, deferred compensation and nontaxable benefits from this organization, with any from related organizations beside each, and the filer's own total. It is shown with the Part VII listing of the same name on the same return. The form gives no key between the two, so that pairing is ours, and is marked matched by us.

Schedule J

Answered yes

  • 4b · Supplemental nonqualified retirement plan

Answered no

  • 4a · Severance or change-of-control payment
  • 4c · Equity-based compensation arrangement
  • 5a · Pay contingent on this organization's revenues
  • 5b · Pay contingent on a related organization's revenues
  • 6a · Pay contingent on this organization's net earnings
  • 6b · Pay contingent on a related organization's net earnings
  • 7 · Other non-fixed payments
  • 8 · Paid under the initial-contract exception

The filer's explanations (Part III)

PART I, LINE 4B
RABBI TRUST CONTRIBUTIONS: DAVE DIETZ $44,320 STEPHEN L. GARWOOD $5,653 MARY ELLEN MORIARTY $6,500

Part I's answers as filed. A line not listed was left unanswered; on lines 1a and 3 that means the box was not checked.

Grants on this return

No itemized grants to organizations on this return.

Related organizations on this return

Schedule R Part II: tax-exempt organizations related to the filer by control. It does not record shared board members or money.

Provenance

Return type
form_990
Tax year
2024
Filed
7 November 2025
IRS schema version
2024v5.2
Source object
202503119349303310

Check it against the return as filed: the GivingTuesday Data Lake hosts a public copy of the original XML.

The source document this was parsed from is served over the API, which is where bulk and document access live.