Form 990 for tax year 2024

Totals

Total revenue

$439,114

Total expenses

$575,032

Contributions and grants received

$395,932

Grants paid

$0

Program service revenue

$63,078

Investment income

$1,376

Other revenue

-$21,272

Total assets, end of year

$149,993

Total liabilities, end of year

$8,419

Net assets or fund balances, end of year

$141,574

Program services expenses (Part IX)

$335,793

Management and general expenses

$144,653

Fundraising expenses

$94,586

Program service expenses (Part III)

$335,793

Program services were 58.4% of total expenses calculated — Part IX's program-services column over total expenses, both as filed.

Line items

Every line the filer filed in Parts VIII, IX and X, as filed and in filed order. Blank columns are left out, and the lines are not forced to add up to the totals above.

Mission and programs · 2024

• Tuesdays at the Boulevard is City on a Hill's longest-running and most iconic outreach event. Hosted six times a year on odd-numbered months, each gathering includes confession, a young adult-led Mass, and a post-Mass social at Boulevard Brewing Co. With an average of 208 attendees per event-over 1,200 cumulative across the year-Tuesdays consistently draws a third of participants who are new to the community. Volunteer teams lead hospitality, liturgical music, and follow-up engagement, making Tuesdays a true "front porch" of our apostolate. The event fosters a low-barrier invitation into Catholic life and often serves as the launching point for young adults to join small groups, retreats, and deeper formation experiences.

  Expenses $174,153 · Revenue $26,083

• In its fifth year, the Guatemala Mission Trip brought 30 young adults, including a priest chaplain, to San Andres Itzapa, Guatemala. Participants served local families by building homes, wood stoves, and animal shelters, and visited a school for children with disabilities. Beyond the physical work, the trip is rooted in spiritual transformation through daily Mass, adoration, confession, and pilgrimage to the site of Blessed Stanley Rother's martyrdom. Many missionaries return home with a deepened sense of faith and a renewed desire to serve. This mission experience continues to be a cornerstone of City on a Hill's formation efforts, blending faith, service, and global solidarity.

  Expenses $74,314

• With 1,146 total registrations and 583 unique participants in 2024, Catholic Challenge Sports (CCS) is one of the largest Catholic recreational sports programs in Kansas City. Year-round leagues in sports like flag football, volleyball, and dodgeball, along with one-day tournaments, offer young adults a structured but welcoming entry point into the life of faith. The CCS draft-based model ensures inclusivity and fosters new friendships, while team captains serve as spiritual anchors-leading prayer, hosting socials, and inviting players into other City on a Hill programs. Over 70% of participants reported involvement in other programs, confirming CCS as one of our strongest engagement pipelines. Survey feedback routinely names CCS as the "greatest value" among City on a Hill offerings. One captain said: "Being a captain is ultimately about service-meeting the deeper needs of those longing for connection within our Roman Catholic family." - Michael Miller, Dodgeball Captain

  Expenses $44,469 · Revenue $25,981

• In 2024, City on a Hill continued to serve hundreds of young adults across the Kansas City metro through a growing network of small groups, retreats, and community-wide events. Our mission remains clear: to inspire and form young adults to become saints through deep relationships and authentic discipleship. With more than 80 volunteers in leadership roles, City on a Hill created spaces for encounter, community, and transformation. Other events include: 1) Sisterhood & Band of Brothers Small Groups - 340 participants (198 women, 142 men) joined weekly discipleship groups led by 52 leaders. These groups provided faith-filled friendship and stability. 2) Undivided Retreat - 56 young adults participated in a weekend of silence, prayer, and fellowship, described by many as transformative. 3) Hospitality & Regional Expansion - KC Underground events averaged 200 attendees. Expansion into the Northland began to serve more young adults where they are. Here is City on a Hill's overall mission impact: 51% reported growing in their relationship with Christ, 82% increased in frequent prayer, 77% grew in engagement with Scripture, 67% became more open to Sacramental Marriage, and 73% of CCS and 61% of Tuesdays attendees joined other City on a Hill programs. Here is a brief summary of our "Leadership & Formation Growth." City on a Hill began transitioning to a calendar-year leadership cycle. Over 80 young adults served as leaders, supported by new mentorship systems and Notion-based planning. One participant shared: "Leadership Equipping Day gave me a paradigm shift: work isn't just provision, but a way to sanctify the world around me." - Ben Chaves

  Expenses $42,857 · Revenue $11,015

As filed on the 2024 return.

Listed in Part VII

• Mary C Suprenant

  Executive Director (January - October)

  Total calculated

  $70,518

  From this org

  $70,518

  From related orgs

  $0

  Other

  $0

  Hours/week

  40

• Fr Andrew Mattingly

  Co-Chaplain (January - July)

  Total calculated

  $35,535

  From this org

  $0

  From related orgs

  $35,535

  Other

  $0

  Hours/week

  7 + 33 related

• Fr Adam Haake

  Co-Chaplain (July - December)

  Total calculated

  $34,510

  From this org

  $0

  From related orgs

  $34,510

  Other

  $0

  Hours/week

  3.5 + 36.5 related

• Greg Doring

  Chair

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  5

• Andrew Flattery

  Treasurer

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  5

• Michele Kueny

  Secretary

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  5

• Sean Cailteux

  Board Member

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  1

• Emily Lopez

  Board Member

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  1

• Ferdinand Niemann

  Board Member (April - December)

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  1

• Paul Rodriguez

  Board Member (April - December)

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  1

• Gordon Schmitz

  Board Member (April - December)

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  1

• Fr Dan Morris

  Co-Chaplain

  Total calculated

  $0

  Hours/week

  8 + 32 related

Compensation is as filed in Part VII: reportable pay from this organization and from related organizations, other compensation, and hours per week. The total, marked calculated, is our sum of the three dollar columns, with a blank column counted as $0; the form itself has no total. On a Form 990-EZ the columns are Part IV's instead, and on a Form 990-PF Part VIII's — compensation, contributions to benefit plans, and expense account — and the total sums those.

Grants on this return

No itemized grants to organizations on this return.

Related organizations on this return

Schedule R Part II: tax-exempt organizations related to the filer by control. It does not record shared board members or money.

• Diocese of Kansas City St Joseph

  501(c)(3) · Sacraments and serving the poor · MO

• Our Lady of Good Counsel

  501(c)3 · Church · MO

• St Margaret of Scotland Catholic Church Lees Summit

  501c3 · Church · MO

• St Pius X Catholic Church

  501(c)(3) · Church · KS

Provenance

Return type

form_990

Tax year

2024

Filed

2 October 2025

IRS schema version

2024v5.0

Source object

202522799349301717

Check it against the return as filed: the GivingTuesday Data Lake hosts a public copy of the original XML.

The source document this was parsed from is served over the API, which is where bulk and document access live.